Anonymous Case List?

I know that this type of thing has never really taken off in the LD community, but would it be possible for people to post summaries of cases they have seen on the vigilante topic on this thread? It could just be anonymous so that debaters who are still debating the topic can write blocks, prepare cases, etc.

Just a thought. I can post whatever I see next weekend, in return.

I'd be willing too, but only if it where more official and more people did it. I think this arbitrary privacy of cases and the like is damaging to development of strat in rounds.

Aff:

1. Social contract = obligation of society to uphold natural law
2. Vigilantes can maintain stability by creating a rule of law
3. Because of the publicity vigilantes get, governments will be afraid of revolution, so will reform.

Neg:

1. Subjective judgment of failure is bad.
2. Vigilantes will be biased.
3. Vigilantes will incite a cycle of violence due to counter-vigilantes.
4. Vigilantes will conduct racist attacks.